Thanks YouTube, But There’s Still a Value Gap

Posted by Russ Crupnick on

In many ways, YouTube is the most valuable asset that the music industry has. It boasts the largest audience for streaming music—in the US MusicWatch estimates their audience at 120M active users. The platform accounts for about one in four music listening hours, according to MusicWatch’s audiocensussm tracking study. Many Americans believe it to be the most influential force for music discovery. And yet we have observed a year in which YouTube has been excoriated by all sorts of stakeholders, from artists to executives—even the acclaimed business manager Irving Azoff took on YouTube. This quarrel has centered on the “value gap,” a term which has joined the music lexicon next to “vinyl,” “EDM” and “Adele.” Put simply, the value gap is a measure of the amount of music purchased or listened to relative to the dollars received by artists and rights holders.

youtube

This week YouTube reported that their 2016 contributions to the music industry will exceed $1B. Considering that IFPI set global digital revenues at nearly $7B (US) last year, the YouTube contribution is a healthy portion of the overall pie. So what’s the problem?

Based on numbers presented by the RIAA, our estimate is that about 30 percent of YouTube revenue filters to the US, or roughly $300M. If first half trends hold up, US streaming revenues will be in the neighborhood of $3.5B, meaning YouTube contributes almost nine percent of revenues. With that 120M user base, ARPU (average revenue per user) is about $2.50 per music listener.

Through Q3 2016 Pandora reported $522M in content acquisition costs. At that run rate the total 2016 expense will be roughly $700M. With 80M active users, Pandora’s industry ARPU is $8.75, or 3.5 times higher than YouTube.

Look at it another way. YouTube has a 27 percent share of music listening in the US and will pay $300M to rights holders, or $11.11M per share point. Pandora has a 27 percent share and pays $700M, or $29.17M per point. Therein lies the value gap. And certainly the YouTube user has much more flexibility to determine how they interact with YouTube, with more options to skip, replay or create individualized playlists.

Therein lies another rub. When we surveyed streamers who claimed YouTube was their primary music listening service:

  • 74% chose it as favorite because it was free
  • 31% chose it because of its on-demand features
  • 26% chose it because there were unlimited song skips

For many YouTube users it operates just like a subscription on-demand service, or at minimum a hybrid of internet radio and on-demand. What is the ARPU for those on-demand services? The rates paid for subscription streaming licenses are privately negotiated but let’s assume stakeholders receive somewhere in the range of 70 percent of revenues. Your $120 annual Spotify Premium or Apple Music subscription nets $84 to artists and rights holders. It is actually lower thanks to discounts, student or family plans, and the sharing of log ins with family members or a friend. But it is still significantly higher than YouTube’s $2.50.

YouTube deserves credit as the most influential music discovery platform. However new MusicWatch research demonstrates that video streamers are MUCH less likely to buy music after they discover it, especially compared with paid streamers, so the ARPU isn’t being made up in downstream sales.

Forget what Irving Azoff believes. Many YouTube users believe that it does what Apple Music and Spotify Premium accomplish, and it does it for a fraction of the ARPU. YouTube’s contribution to the music industry is important and significant. But until the revenue contribution better aligns with its artistic contribution, expect to hear more on the value gap.

Comments

  20. Heather on said:

    Experience the best entertainment options available today, including exclusive performances and events. For those interested in attending a ücretli show, there are numerous opportunities to enjoy high-quality shows. Whether you’re looking for a night out with friends or a special occasion, these events provide memorable experiences. Be sure to check the schedule and book your tickets in advance. Attending a ücretli show can truly enhance your entertainment experience.

  21. Nathan on said:

    İç Anadolu’nun güzellikleri arasında yer alan ve tarihi zenginlikleriyle ünlü olan bölge, ziyaretçilerine unutulmaz deneyimler sunar. Doğal güzellikleri ve kültürel mirasıyla dikkat çeken bu yerler, özellikle manavgat escort gibi turistik noktalarla doludur. Tarihi kalıntıları ve doğal oluşumlarıyla büyüleyici bir atmosfere sahip olan bölge, her yıl binlerce turisti ağırlar. Bu nedenle, gezilecek yerler listesinde mutlaka bulunması gereken bir destinasyondur.

  22. Lara on said:

    Antalya’nın güzel ilçelerinden biri olan ve eşsiz doğasıyla bilinen manavgat escort, ziyaretçilerine unutulmaz deneyimler sunuyor. Şelaleleri ve tarihi yapılarıyla dikkat çeken bu bölge, doğa severler ve tarih tutkunları için ideal bir destinasyon. Ayrıca, manavgat aynı zamanda canlı pazarları ve lezzetli yemekleriyle de öne çıkıyor. Tatil planı yapanların mutlaka görmesi gereken bir yer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *